The Gray Areas of Islamic Law and Morality
Question: Are halal and haram moral categories?
Answer: Yes, they can be moral categories in two ways, in our relationship with others and in our relationship with God. Disobeying God while not directly harming others is still immoral.
Question: What is a gray area in Islamic law?
Answer: It is an area where it isn’t clear cut whether an action is morally good or bad, but in the law, it may be a point where we’re not sure about, or be something that is reprehensible but permissible (makrūh)
Question: Can you name an example of a makrūh act which God dislikes but allows anyways?
Answer: Divorce
Question: If there is a gray area in Islam, should we approach it or leave it?
Answer: The Prophet (s) taught us to leave it as it risks leading us into sin
Question: How does something mubāh become mustahab?
Answer: By changing one’s intention in wanting to please God.